I probably gave something like 18-12-10 to an entry in the last round,
First Encounter.  The entry was a view up into the bottom of some kind
of mushroom-shaped spacecraft.  The entry had a brilliant collection of
bright colors.

ARTISTIC:     Wow. That is pretty.  Neat screensaver. Neat T-shirt. Neat
wall decoration in my living room.
TECHNICAL: Hmm.  Probably not that hard to make, just lights and
coloring.
CONCEPT:     Nah.  A spaceship?  Whoo-peee.

In thinking about cross-contamination more, I think I've both been the
victim of it badly, and I think that I may be a pepretrator, and I think
that it's a too easy criticism to make of a rating you disagree with.

Fabien Mosen wrote:

> just curious :
> could you cite me an image (even from past rounds) that
> deserves a vote like 20-10-12 or 10-9-16 or anything like that ?
> I don't remember seeing one, even after 16 months of IRTC.
>
> Cheers,
> Fabien.

Post a reply to this message